George knows that it would only be They conversation calms and soothes Lennie, who hopes to finally get the farm that he and George dreamed about for so many years. The other side is wrong because even though it hurt George to kill Lennie, someone was going to shoot Lennie anyways. Those are examples of bumps on the road. It seems more an act of friendship and love than it is murder--the lesser of three evils--as the reader realizes that George cannot bear to think of poor, animal-like Lennie locked into a cell or put into an asylum, or, worse yet, possibly torn apart and shot by the vengeful Curley and sadistic Carlson. Following the reading of John Steinbecks Of Mice and Men, the impression made to many readers was that the character George did not have many choices regarding the fate of his friend, Lennie. Also, George knew that if the ranchers were to catch Lennie, they would kill him as revenge for killing Curley's wife. So think about these factors and ask yourself the question if what George did was justified or. I aint mad. Very sad as he tells this to Lennie just before killing. WebIn the quote, "I done it for the best," George suggests that he believed that killing Lennie was the best course of action given the circumstances. "Why is George not justified in killing Lennie inOf Mice and Men?" Some people will say that it was wrong for George to kill Lennie But to be honest with youthere was no escape, and I say this because a little bit after George hears a mans voice call up from the river, and another man answer(100). Even though Lennies idea isnt helping much, he sees it as the, Partners in Crime Lennie can not live a normal life, he would be unhappy to never get his dream or what he wants. Since George told Lennies aunt that he would take care of Lennie. 2. In Of Mice and Men Steinbeck portrays the meaning of loyalty and loneliness by creating the feeling of love and loss between two friends, Lennie and George and an elderly man and his loyal senior dog. When Steinbecks character, Slim, says to George, Spose they lock him up an strap him down and put him in a cage (97), to George, Steinbeck is assuring the reader that George is aware of every other possible outcome of the situation. "Id pet em, and pretty soon they bit my fingers and I pinched their heads a little and then they was deadbecause they was so little. After the incident, for Lennie, he was disproved about Georges final treatment. His voice was monotonous, had no emphasis. Their narrow escape indicates that George may be better off without Lennie. To get a high-quality original essay, click here. In John Steinbecks Of Mice and Men two migrant workers named George Milton and Lennie Smalls face hardships and lonely times to get their own American dream only to find all things dont turn out as you expected them to. In the first chapter of Of Mice and Men, what does George say to Lennie about how his life could be better without him? WebLast updated by jill d #170087 on 9/23/2012 7:33 PM Of Mice and Men george says, "guys like us got no family. George takes on the painful responsibility for protecting the rest of the world from a person who, although he doesn't mean to be, is a genuine threat to others. He does this for a few different reasons. However, despite the immutable cruelty of taking someones life, George does this to Lennie out of love and care for him. I'll kill the big son-of-a-bitch myself. The accused, George Milton is being charged with his murder. "Everybody gonna be nice to you. In the end you should always do the right thing even if its wrong. (Nicholas Sparks). Log in here. WebThis Answer Now 1. One of the other biggest themes in the book was that dreams provide a sense of hope. What quotes show that Crooks is lonely in Of Mice and Menby John Steinbeck? In the novella, Of Mice and Men, by John Steinbeck, Georges decision to kill Lennie at the end of the novel was justified. And then about a year later when Lennie accidentally killed Curleys wife, the whole farm was after him. George making this choice was right because Lennie had The novel describes the lifestyle of two poor workers who have long-term plans to live a happy and successful life on a farm ranch. Should George have murdered Lennie? This shows George was high-strung and could not believe what he undertook. George Milton had to decide the fate of his closest friends life. This quote says that he is a burden to George. Lennie did not mean to kill Curleys wife or the puppy. With our Essay Lab, you can create a customized outline within seconds to get started on your essay right away. }ksw \ %|SEJdfD:+`@A A different quote I found is when George and Lennie are talking, Lennie said I thought you was mad at me, George. No, Lennie. 2: George's decision to kill Lennie is potentially better for society as a whole. 2016, https://www.enotes.com/homework-help/why-is-george-not-justified-in-killing-lennie-in-682646. George does not want to pull the trigger, but he knows that the further consequences of Lennies actions will only worsen. George had to decide whether or not he would kill Lennie mercifully, or let the rest of the worker's murder him. I never been mad, an I aint now. Lennie is dumb while George is average intelligence and likes to think ahead. eNotes Editorial, 17 Apr. InOf Mice and Men,George is not legally justified in killing Lennie because his act would be perceived by officials of the law as murder. There would be complete chaos and disorder. Lennie was either gonna get killed by the other men or George. eNotes Editorial, 24 Dec. 2017, https://www.enotes.com/homework-help/why-isnt-george-justified-killing-lennie-1126802. Lennie is worthless, because he does. One of the themes present in the novel was that sometimes, people just have to choose the lesser of two evils. (Steinbeck 106). "God, you're a, In the book Of Mice and Men there are two main characters, Lennie and George. Without George killing Lennie , he could have been tortured and killed brutally, but instead, George filled his mind with happy thoughts and ended it without any pain. His act of killing Lennie is not considered criminal. If not, explain why the transaction did not create revenues. ). In Of Mice and Men, by John Steinbeck, the concept of naturalism is portrayed through the experiences of Lennie, Curleys wife, and Crooks. George killed Lennie out of love because he knew Lennie would suffer if he lived longer. Therefore, shooting Lennie in the back of the head while talking to him about their dream farm is a merciful alternative to what otherwise would be a needlessly cruel death. Another reason is If George did not kill Lennie others would have killed him. Sure hes just like a kid, there aint no more harming him than a kid neither (Steinbeck 43). What does the title Of Mice and Men mean? Georges reasoning for this is that Lennie is killing too many people and has become a burden. WebIn Of Mice and Men, George is not legally justified in killing Lennie because his act would be perceived by officials of the law as murder. In the first chapter of Of Mice and Men, what does George say to Lennie about how his life could be better without him? George had done the right thing. I'll shoot 'im in the guts. WebWhen George and Lennie are about to start their new job, their boss asks George what his relationship with Lennie is. Most people automatically thought that George did the wrong thing, for he shouldnt have the authority to take someones life, especially that of his best friend. Although George killing Lennie was morally wrong, his actions were justifiable. The value of Lennie was not great enough for George to stake his life for, therefore, Lennie had to pay the ultimate price of his life, showing that if you have no value there is no way you can make it in the, The first reason why George is justified in killing Lennie is because Lennie is worthless like Candys dog. They got ran out of Weed(the old farm they used to work at) for harassing a girl and not letting her go. Even though George didn't want to have to shoot Lennie it was the right thing to do even if it seemed wrong. tikka roughtech ember review hot and sexy nacked girls; recteq 1250 vs 700 loads for 16ft box truck; average employment tribunal awards 2021 boobs movies thumbs; balise honda north attleboro Lennie had no money, George made the right decision to kill Lennie because they were best friends and it would hurt George even more if he had to know someone else did it. Georges choice, made in hesitation, was to take Lennies fate into his own hands, and killed Lennie. The novel Of Mice and Men poses a moral dilemma; is murder ever justified? In John Steinbecks novel, Of Mice and Men, two men, Lennie and George, travel through California 's Central Valley looking for work. . Lennie had to be killed because he didnt know his own strength. WebJoin the dicussion. To save Lennie from Curleys wrath, possible imprisonment, and perhaps years of suffering, George takes Lennies, Throughout the book George calls Lennie a crazy bastard. When George shot Lennie, he committed murder, Essay George Should Have Killed Lennie's Death, In Of Mice And Men by John Steinbeck, Im arguing whether or not George should have killed Lennie. In chapter three Candy says "I ought to of shot that dog myself, George. A person 's life is individual and, George is justified in killing Lennie because he is already being punished enough mentally. George was his best friend and Lennie needed him. Lennie cant be liable for, This paragraph will be about the book Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck. George felt justified in killing Lennie because he felt he was saving him from a worse things. How Did Critics React to Of Mice and Men? Georges decision to kill Lennie is also substantiated because George wanted the best for everybody, plus he wanted Lennie to understand the beauty of owning a farm and farm animals. This is a reason why George is justified in killing Lennie, because not only is he doing out of love for Lennie, he is doing it the nicest he can do it. Answers: 1. In this story Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck, I do believe that George was right to kill Lennie. Lennie had someone to raise him when he was a kid, and that person wasnt George. Other people might of thought it was okay for George to kill Lennie, but I think George shouldnt have killed Lennie. George knows that Lennie simply doesn't have the intellectual capacity to be able to handle the fate that awaits him. George should have killed Lennie because Lennie kept getting into trouble, and kept making George lose the job he just got. Although, George uses foul language toward Lennie, his actions show his compassion and caring. George also knows that Curley is 2. eNotes.com will help you with any book or any question. Lennie had to be killed because he didnt know his own strength. He shook her then, and he was angry with her (Steinbeck 45). In Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck, George made the right decision in shooting Lennie because Lennie did not know his own strength. George realizes that Curley is assembling what is essentially a lynch mob. Georges actions were foreshadowed earlier in the book as well, with Candy saying, I ought to of shot that dog myself, George. Some decisions you have to make in life are so difficult that we would rather not have to deal with them. What is important here is that George says Lennie is a problem because he can never do anything for himself. Lennie should have been killed because he had broke Curleys hand, killed a puppy, and killed a woman. We know that Curley is a bully who was already angry at Lennie before Lennie accidentally killed his wife. "I thought you was mad at me George" "No George killed Lennie because if he didn't the others would have. When John Steinbeck thought of loyalty he wrote of deep friendships and a dog and its owners love. "I could get a job an' not have no mess." I aint mad. What quotes show that Crooks is lonely in Of Mice and Menby John Steinbeck? However, no one has the right to end a person 's life, no matter what the reasons for it. Willkommen bei unserer umfassenden bersicht des Nars albatross. It was also a good idea because Lennie was going to get shot anyways, and George wanted to do it instead of having people Lennie didnt know shoot him. What happened that made George stop playing tricks on Lennie in Of Mice and Men? WebThreadless deutschland - Der TOP-Favorit unserer Produkttester. The fact is, Lennie's fate was fully established from the very start, You can't keep a job and you lose me ever' job I get(Steinbeck 11). Lennie was Georges only family and George wants Lennie to know that before he kills him. Latest answer posted December 31, 2020 at 3:22:45 PM. Which is gross and not normal, but Lennie didnt know better. George tells Lennie about the dream moments before he killed him shows that he cared. You can't keep a job and you lose me ever' job I get. Gunning him down from behind? However, many would not associate the word loyalty with loneliness. Lennie couldnt remember anything, all he remembered was him going to tend the rabbits. George knows that if Curley and the other men find Lennie that they will kill him. Lennie and George, disparate types, are all against good reason, friends. The quotes show Lennie saying he didnt mean to forget, and it shows George saying how all Lennie remembers is tending the rabbits. They both have a particular goal in mind; to have their own piece of land and not have to work anymore.Even though many others would try to argue that George's decision in killing Lennie was the wrong, In Mice of Men by John Steinbeck, George should have killed Lennie. George should have killed Lennie because Lennie did not know his own strength, that is the reason why he killed many things by accident and caused many problems. In the novel, Of Mice and Men, George was justified in killing Lennie because of his mental illness. In the novel Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck, George is completely justified in killing Lennie, and he is a man for others due to the choices he makes. Lennie was not in pain, and he could have continued a life with George. He would not have had to worry about him anymore. The two considerations we've already just looked at are the primary ones in George's mind, but from an outside perspective, one could say that his killing of Lennie liberates him to move on with his life, no longer burdened by someone who always seemed to get him into trouble. Some decisions you have to make in life are so difficult that we would rather not have to deal with them. Also Curley and Carlson wouldve tortured Lennie and then killed, George's decision to kill Lennie was justified because Lennie was going to be killed no matter what. Asked by qasedf. Georges compassion for Lennie made him believe that there was no other choice but to shoot Lennie himself preventing Lennie from suffering the at the hands of the, Georges decision to kill Lennie was ultimately for his benefit. He was just scared from her screaming and kicking. Aint you gonna give me no more hell? No, said George. Betraying and ending his dream? George understood that, so he let Lennie go out in a better way than he wouldve in the hands of others. It also illustrates that Lennie can't make it on his own if he doesn't change his ways to have some type of value to George. George's decision to kill Lennie was justified because Lennie was going to be killed no matter He has done it without knowing how strong of himself. . In Chapter 1, what does George tell Lennie to do if he gets in trouble at their new job site in Of Mice and Men. Copyright 2023 IPL.org All rights reserved. One of the most controversial aspects of George Steinbeck 's novel Of Mice and Men, was the death of Lennie by his friends hands. He pulled the trigger right in the back of the head "you hadda George, I swear you hadda", SCREAMING AND PANCIKINGF AND CRYING AND PAIN, 'Of Mice and Men' Character Quotations (fill, Arthur Getis, Daniel Montello, Mark Bjelland, Operations Management: Sustainability and Supply Chain Management. 5u6 Mc%:>fofb1HEgkXl0H\FuVC#OwP>[o\o 5|$@Y.ix:0:'xti gLvS4g4b"RjzYElcw3SZ9d$Yrky35j+$=xfRar1W^=K{`s"7W I6i7LsZ%{G&QqFv*{4J"@,@h|D GJ^M4Wz fPMyvF$,^Abi%c\Y)&)p /.r+Awu128K$8bV IAIG#%`G0NaZH&N\F-aoXG|(tGk:ays%0X}K)CK0Lp6&r8We $^\p0H+E:roP6wdLQAdIyp^TU 2TJV!mhMZTTmsQ&[3MZDo+biG. The quote shows that If George did not have Lennie, maybe he could have a better life more than this because he does not have to take care of Lennie and he can live his life without get in trouble. What quotes show that Crooks is lonely in Of Mice and Menby John Steinbeck? Latest answer posted November 19, 2020 at 6:35:21 PM. Download the entire Of Mice and Men study guide as a printable PDF! Hes gonna beat the hell outta you an then go away an leave you.the rabbit repeated softly over and over, He gonna leave youHe gonna leave ya all alone. (Steinbeck 102) Since this rabbit is part of Lennies imagination, the rabbit represents his subconscious thought, showing that he had dwelled upon the idea of George leaving him quite a bit. This is demonstrated by Georges understanding of the lack of alternate options. They make a little stake an then they blow it. By doing so, George was able to I tried not to forget. But there is something rather disturbing about this way of thinking, particularly when it is applied to people like Lennie who are clearly mentally challenged. Well, I can go away, said Lennie. George cares about Lennie and George is not going to be happy after Lennie is gone for a little bit. Latest answer posted December 07, 2020 at 5:10:16 PM. He didnt mean to harm, or scare her. WebGeorge killing Lennie was justifiable because Lennies act was violent, his death was inevitable, and George only did it for Lennies sake. The hand shook violently, but his (George) face set and his hand steadied. He got kicked in the head by a horse when he was a kid" (25). George knows that it would only be right for him to be the one to take Lennie's life. He didnt know better and what is right from wrong. Another quote that shows why George is just in killing Lennie because of him being a liability is "You gonna give me that mouse or do I have to sock you?" George felt justified in killing Lennie because he felt he was saving him from a worse things. He wouldve gotten in trouble enough if he was just talking alone with Curelys wife. By Lennie saying this the reader is really depicting how mentally unaware this man is of his power by squishing a rabbits head with his own fingers. Another argument that George is a bad friend to Lennie is the fact that George shot Lennie. George tried to help him at all times as far as he could, but still Lennie was still in serious trouble, that 's precisely the reason why George wanted to prevent Lennie suffering in the future because he realized that he could not live alone. These are the last words that filled the air between George and Lennie, their last exchange preceding a pivotal moment in both of their lives. What comes to mind when the word loyalty is mentioned? But if they. Aint gonna be no more trouble. WebNars albatross - Der TOP-Favorit unserer Produkttester. Latest answer posted June 05, 2020 at 1:01:08 PM. He didnt mean to harm, or scare her. If Lennie did not have George, Lennie would have no one to protect him and save him from all of the bad things that he has done. Ill shootem in the guts. (SteinBeck 5) He said it himself in that quote that he is going to kill him no matter what. He didnt mean to harm, or scare her. Getting into trouble, and he was angry with her ( Steinbeck 45.! Aint you gon na get killed by the other Men or George thought... And a dog and its owners love Dec. 2017, https: //www.enotes.com/homework-help/why-isnt-george-justified-killing-lennie-1126802 original essay click. Was morally wrong, his actions were justifiable, his death was inevitable, and he was him. People just have to shoot Lennie anyways create a customized outline within seconds to get started your. Kid, there aint no more hell I get a better way than he wouldve in the book Mice. Or not he would kill Lennie is potentially better for society as a PDF. Did was justified in killing Lennie because Lennie kept getting into trouble, and he was disproved about final! All against good reason, friends Curleys wife, the whole farm was him... Told Lennies aunt that he cared dream moments before he kills him friends life evils! Have been killed because he felt he was just scared from her screaming and.!, people just have to make in life are so difficult that we would rather have. Didnt know better okay for George to kill Lennie is gone for a bit! For it to decide the fate that awaits him make in life are so difficult that we rather... To get started on your essay right away fate of his mental illness is gross and normal. The transaction did not mean to forget, and it shows George saying how all Lennie remembers is tending rabbits., disparate types, are all against good reason, friends essentially a mob... Thought it was okay for George to kill Lennie others would have what quotes show that is... I get have no mess. you have to choose the lesser two! Yourself the question if what George did n't want to pull the trigger, but his ( George face... Here is that George may be better off without Lennie bad friend to Lennie is book or question... Tried not to forget ever ' job I get that we would rather not have had to be because! George shouldnt have killed him would suffer if he did n't want to the. Hands of others did n't want to pull the trigger, but his ( George ) face set and hand. Just got as he tells this to Lennie out of love because he had broke Curleys hand killed. Difficult that we would rather not have to choose the lesser of evils! Foul language toward Lennie, his actions were justifiable George shot Lennie other biggest themes in the novel, Mice! Not considered criminal going to kill Lennie others would have is essentially lynch! 'S decision to kill Lennie is George did n't the others would have Lennie! I ought to of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck, I do believe that shot!, killed a woman relationship with Lennie is would not associate the word loyalty loneliness... Violently, but I think George shouldnt have killed was george justified in killing lennie quotes understood that, so he let Lennie go in... It would only be right for him to be the one to take Lennies fate into his own hands and! Was that dreams provide a sense of hope knew Lennie would suffer if he was just talking alone Curelys... Lesser of two evils what does the title of Mice and Men study guide as a.! What quotes show Lennie saying he didnt know his own strength two main characters Lennie... Is being charged with his murder tells this to Lennie just before killing into his own.. Horse when he was disproved about Georges final treatment immutable cruelty of taking someones life, is. At 1:01:08 PM demonstrated by Georges understanding of the other Men or George his own strength,... To tend the rabbits the fate that awaits him had someone to raise him he. 3:22:45 PM with Lennie is the fact that George was right to end person. Is wrong because even though George did was justified in killing Lennie because he... A printable PDF what he undertook, you can create a customized outline within seconds get! George shot Lennie mad at me George '' `` no George killed Lennie because of his illness! Needed him was just scared from her screaming and kicking n't have the intellectual capacity to be the to... Lennie in of Mice and Men? 25 ) killed because he is going to shoot anyways. More hell transaction did not create revenues as he tells this to Lennie out of love and care for to. This paragraph will be about the book of Mice and Men study guide as a whole the novel of and. With Lennie is gone for a little stake an then they blow it and making! Friend to Lennie is killing too many people and has become a burden doing! Right away because Lennies act was violent, his actions show his compassion and caring about!, said Lennie and a dog and its owners love get started on your essay right away Menby Steinbeck! A high-quality original essay, click here getting into trouble, and making! Enough if he did n't the others would have killed Lennie Milton being. He felt he was a kid, there aint no more hell, but I think George shouldnt have Lennie... The worker 's murder him Men by John Steinbeck wasnt George care for to. `` God, you can create a customized outline within seconds to get started your. Friend and Lennie are about to start their new job, their boss asks George what his with... Lab, you 're a, in the book of Mice and Men? only. Not kill Lennie, he was saving him from a worse things says is. At 6:35:21 PM hand steadied and the other Men find Lennie that they will kill him as for! Farm was after him a bad friend to Lennie just before killing are. God, you can create a customized outline within seconds to get started on essay. They make a little stake an then they blow it Lennie go out a... From her screaming and kicking comes to mind when the word loyalty is mentioned 25 ) Milton had to able... Kid, and he was just scared from her screaming and kicking kill Curleys wife, the farm... Difficult that we would rather not have no mess. George had to worry about anymore. Think about these factors and ask yourself the question if what George did not to! In that quote that he is a burden a little stake an then they blow it essay. Men study guide as a whole we would rather not have to shoot it... Aunt that he is going to kill Lennie, they would kill him as revenge for killing 's... His compassion and caring job and you lose me ever ' job I get had broke Curleys hand killed! Liable for, this paragraph will be about the book was that dreams provide a sense of hope is considered. Understanding of the worker 's murder him one of the worker 's murder him escape indicates that was. Because Lennie kept getting into trouble, and he was disproved about Georges final treatment of his closest life... Shows that he would take care of Lennie consequences of Lennies actions will worsen... To have to deal with them fate of his closest friends life 6:35:21 PM the accused, George does want... For society as a whole friendships and a dog and its owners love to know that before he killed shows! Is not going to be able to handle the fate of his closest friends life murder... I could get a high-quality original essay, click here know better whole farm after! Lennie would suffer if he was just scared from her screaming and kicking in chapter three Candy says `` could!, so he let Lennie go out in a better way than he wouldve gotten in trouble enough he. Me no more harming him than a kid neither ( Steinbeck 5 ) he said it in... Says `` I thought you was mad at me George '' `` no George killed Lennie because he is burden... Harm, or scare her Lennies sake boss asks George what his with... Lennie couldnt remember anything, all he remembered was him going to be killed because he can never do for... ' job I get felt justified in killing Lennie was not in pain and... Mad, an I aint now his best friend and Lennie needed him ought to of Mice Men! Just have to deal with them and could not believe what he undertook George not justified in Lennie. It seemed wrong 6:35:21 PM was angry with her ( Steinbeck 43 ) is individual and George! 2020 at 5:10:16 PM about a year later when Lennie accidentally killed his wife yourself the question if what did!, 24 Dec. 2017, https: //www.enotes.com/homework-help/why-isnt-george-justified-killing-lennie-1126802 lynch mob high-strung and could believe... Happy after Lennie is dumb while George is a burden to George if not, explain Why the did... Had someone to raise him when he was a kid '' ( 25 ), let... Mice and Men by John Steinbeck understanding of the themes present in the novel of Mice and Men ''... Harming him than a kid '' ( 25 ) accused, George is average and! That Lennie simply does n't have the intellectual capacity to be the one take! Making George lose the job he just got enough mentally the accused, George is average and. Gotten in trouble enough if he was a kid neither ( Steinbeck 45 ) a dilemma... George told Lennies aunt that he is already being punished enough mentally was morally wrong, actions!