Dave has rated thousands and thousands of match on a scale of 0-5 (or higher) since the very first edition of the Observer came out, and his scores are still highly regarded and coveted by those in the industry. Without further ado, let's take a look at 10 wrestling matches that Dave Meltzer has over rated. To date he has rated 208 matches five stars (or above). Also, this match was nothing like the fantastic match that Kota Ibushi and SANADA had the year before, and that's precisely why fans were a little disappointed in this one. You call this Harpo Marx motherfucker a goddamn "genius" at match layout, better'n Flair/Steamboat, blah fuckin blah. At time of writing, Dave has only given out 200 5+ star ratings in over 40 years of grading matches. Aside from providing insider knowledge (and annoying Jim Cornette), Meltzer is also known for his star rating system. Perhaps 5 stars was a little too much for a match which had a predictable winner, but their fluidity and impressive spots are well worth the acclaim that this bout received, adding a classic to Omegas great title reign. Without further delay, hereare the 10 worst wrestling matches according to Dave Meltzer. Despite being the babyface, Steamboat brought out great aggression and a hard-hitting style in this match, doing what he needed to do to win, with him not being bothered about making it look pretty. The wrestling promoters booked the show and in hundreds of closed-circuit locations around the country. Unique lists featuring pop culture, entertainment and crazy facts. Following his push to the main event status, Michaels name became synonymous with incredible matches. Dave Meltzer Star Ratings - Wrestlemania 10 (X) - Bret Hart vs. Owen Hart. 10 Wrestling Matches Dave Meltzer Over Rated, The Inner Circle Vs. American Top Team & Men Of The Year - AEW Full Gear 2021 (4 Stars), Brock Lesnar Vs. Dean Ambrose vs. Roman Reigns Fastlane 2016 (4 Stars), Kenny Omega Vs. Rich Swann - Impact Wrestling Rebellion 2021 (4 Stars), Bobby Roode Vs. Shinsuke Nakamura - WWE NXT TakeOver: Orlando (4 Stars), Kota Ibushi Vs. SANADA - NJPW G1 Climax 2019 (4 Stars), Kazuchika Okada Vs. SANADA - NJPW Wrestling Dontaku 2019 (4 Stars), Jeff Cobb Vs. Kazuchika Okada - NJPW Wrestle Grand Slam In MetLife Dome (4 Stars), Marty Jannetty Vs. Shawn Michaels Monday Night Raw (4 Stars), Bandido Vs. Dragon Lee - PWG Battle Of Los Angeles 2019 (5 Stars), Christian Cage & The Jurassic Express Vs. Finn Blor e Rhea Ripley vs. Dave and Bryan hosted the show every Sunday night from 8:00 to 10:00 p.m. EST on the Sports Byline Radio Network. The three collided for Triple Hs World Heavyweight Championship in the main event. Meltzer has run with things that started off as a joke on Twitter, like the "WWE Intermission PPV." If he had credible sources, he wouldn't ever considering reporting things where his source material is so shoddy. Omega and Okada would also win the PWI Feud of the Year in 2017, the first time a feud from a wrestling company outside the Unites States would win that award. When it comes to the 10 best-rated title matches in AEW, per Dave Meltzer, the AEW World Championship, Tag Team Titles, and TNT Championship all make an appearance. Someone please feed some brains in his head and his subscribers. He rates them on a 5-star scale [here are all of the five-star ratings that he has ever given out]. In TNA, more of the same. This I Quit Match main evented the entire show, and it is easy to see why it had that spot with it being a wild brawl, and something crazier than most matches that had been seen on TV at the time. The blue brand benefited the most from the split as the 'SmackDown Six' all got to showcase their potential under the watchful eye of Paul Heyman. Pro wrestling pundit and critic Dave Meltzer knows what makes a good bout, but he also saw some of the worst. The Undertaker, 5* | Fri, Jun 6th 1997 | AJPW Budokan Hall Show | Mitsuharu Misawa vs. Toshiaki Kawada, 5* | Thu, Jun 5th 1997 | NJPW Best Of The Super Juniors IV | El Samurai vs. Koji Kanemoto, 5* | Sun, Mar 23rd 1997 | WWF WrestleMania 13 | Bret Hart vs. Steve Austin, 5* | Fri, Dec 6th 1996 | AJPW Budokan Hall Show | Akira Taue, Toshiaki Kawada, Jun Akiyama, Mitsuharu Misawa, 5* | Fri, Jun 7th 1996 | AJPW Budokan Hall Show | Jun Akiyama, Mitsuharu Misawa vs. Johnny Ace, Steve Williams, 5* | Sat, Mar 9th 1996 | ECW Big Ass Extreme Bash | Rey Misterio, Jr. vs. Juventud Guerrera, 5* | Fri, Jun 9th 1995 | AJPW Budokan Hall Show | Akira Taue, Toshiaki Kawada, Kenta Kobashi, Mitsuharu Misawa, 5* | Sat, Apr 15th 1995 | AJPW Budokan Hall Show | Mitsuharu Misawa vs. Akira Taue, 5* | Sat, Mar 4th 1995 | AJPW Budokan Hall Show | Kenta Kobashi, Mitsuharu Misawa vs. Johnny Ace, Steve Williams, 5* | Sun, Nov 6th 1994 | WCW/AAA When Worlds Collide | El Hijo Del Santo, Octagon, Eddy Guerrero, Art Barr, 5* | Mon, Aug 29th 1994 | WWF SummerSlam | Bret Hart vs. Owen Hart, 5* | Sat, Apr 16th 1994 | NJPW Super J Cup | Wild Pegasus vs. Top three matches of 2021: SmackDown vs. Roman Reigns; Dynamite "Grand Slam" vs. Kenny Omega; Dynamite "Winter is Coming" vs. "Hangman" Adam Page. Emotions were at an all-time high as The Rock took on Hogan in an "icon vs. icon" match at WrestleMania X8. Since 1982, respected fan of wrestling and author of the Wrestling Observer, Dave Meltzer, has been rating matches from all across the globe. Danielsons heel work helped to carry the opening half of the match, with him making even their stalling entertaining. When he's not writing about pro wrestling, he's watching it. On the other hand, Boogeymans offense was quite terrible. It was a Street Fight in every sense of the word and involved the use of gnarling foreign objects. This match is simply one of the most annoying and insulting events in the history of professional wrestling. While the Attitude Era produced some of the greatest matches in WWEs history, it also produced some of the worst ones as well. What followed was an incredible display of action and athleticism. It could be argued that Meltzers rating for this match was a little too high, as it certainly wasnt completely perfect, with some very slow moments and a predictable nature, but it was still a very enjoyable battle for the Tag Team Titles. successfully defending his World Heavyweight Championship. Whilst the result wasnt really in doubt, the four men did enough to get the crowd rocking for this tremendous title bout. Ric Flair has finally wrestled his last match, which makes it high time to look at what Dave Meltzer has rated to be his 10 greatest ever matches. Lex Luger Vs. Meng - Halloween Havoc 1995 . 7* | Sat, Jun 9th 2018 | NJPW Dominion 6.9 In Osaka-Jo Hall | Kenny Omega vs. Kazuchika Okada (2 Out Of 3 Falls), 6.25* | Sun, Jun 11th 2017 | NJPW Dominion 6.11 | Kazuchika Okada vs. Kenny Omega, 6* | Sat, Aug 12th 2017 | NJPW G1 Climax 2017 - Day 18 | Kenny Omega vs. Kazuchika Okada, 6* | Wed, Jan 4th 2017 | NJPW Wrestle Kingdom XI | Kazuchika Okada vs. Kenny Omega, 6* | Fri, Jun 3rd 1994 | AJPW Budokan Hall Show | Mitsuharu Misawa vs. Toshiaki Kawada, 5.75* | Sun, Aug 12th 2018 | NJPW G1 Climax 2018 - Day 19 | Hiroshi Tanahashi vs. Kota Ibushi (G1 CLIMAX FINAL), 5.75* | Sun, Aug 13th 2017 | NJPW G1 Climax 2017 - Day 19 | Tetsuya Naito vs. Kenny Omega (G1 CLIMAX FINAL), 5.5* | Sat, Aug 11th 2018 | NJPW G1 Climax 2018 - Day 18 | Kota Ibushi vs. Kenny Omega, 5.5* | Sat, Aug 4th 2018 | NJPW G1 Climax 2018 - Day 14 | Tomohiro Ishii vs. Kenny Omega, 5.5* | Mon, Jun 4th 2018 | NJPW Best Of The Super Juniors XXV - Day 14 | Hiromu Takahashi vs, Taiji Ishimori, 5.5* Fri, May 4th 2018 | NJPW Wrestling Dontaku 2018 - Day 2 | Kazuchika Okada vs. Hiroshi Tanahashi, 5* | Fri, Aug 10th 2018 | NJPW G1 Climax 2018 - Day 17 | Hiroshi Tanahashi vs. Kazuchika Okada, 5* | Sat, Jul 21st 2018 | NJPW G1 Climax 2018 - Day 6 | Tomohiro Ishii vs. Hirooki Goto, 5* | Sat, Apr 7th 2018 | NXT Takeover: New Orleans | Johnny Gargano vs. Tommaso Ciampa (Unsanctioned), 5* | Sat, Apr 7th 2018 | NXT Takeover: New Orleans | Adam Cole, EC3, Killian Dain, Lars Sullivan, Ricochet, The Velveteen Dream (Ladder 6-Way), 5* | Sun, Apr 1st 2018 | NJPW Sakura Genesis 2018 | Will Ospreay vs. Marty Scurll, 5* | Sun, Mar 25th 2018 | NJPW Strong Style Evolved | Kota Ibushi, Kenny Omega vs. Nick Jackson, Matt Jackson, 5* | Sat, Jan 27th 2018 | NXT TakeOver: Philadelphia | Andrade "Cien" Almas vs. Johnny Gargano, 5* | Thu, Jan 4th 2018 | NJPW WrestleKingdom 12 | Kenny Omega vs. Chris Jericho (No Disqualification). Since 1982, respected fan of wrestling and author of the Wrestling Observer, Dave Meltzer, has been rating matches from all across the globe.Of all the matches he has rated over the years, these . This has been one of the weaker bouts in the Okada-SANADA rivalry, as it was basically the same as their other matches, except this time there is little excitement and the storytelling was pretty basic. For this year's WrestleMania 39 event at SoFi Stadium in Los Angeles on April 1st & April 2nd, Lesnar has been rumored for a few different matches including the likes of GUNTHER and a . dave the last few years you have acted as an anti-WWE and you have fed that hatred towards a company and certain pro wrestling fans who hate wwe have sheltered with you and that is why when you do an awards vote on your page it seems corrupted and bought by @TonyKhan There are several matches that Meltzer has over rated, and admittedly he is giving five-star (or higher) ratings more often than ever, which has ruined the meaning and value of the stars. There have been 218 matches awarded 5 or more stars; Mitsuharu Misawa and Will Ospreay are tied for the most individual matches with 25 apiece. List of professional wrestling matches rated 5 or more stars by Dave Meltzer, Wrestlers with the most 5-or-higher-star matches, Wrestlers with the most higher-than-5-star matches, Promotions with the most 5-or-higher-star matches, Promotions with the most higher-than-5-star matches, Last edited on 23 February 2023, at 03:54, World Wrestling Federation/World Wrestling Entertainment, Asistencia Asesora y Administracin/Lucha Libre AAA Worldwide, Professional wrestling in the United Kingdom, Professional wrestling in the United States, "Dave Meltzer on Twitter: "I was there. Writer: The Life & Times of Abdullah the Butcher. From Episode 196 of Jim Cornette's Drive ThruArtwork by Travis Heckel!Send in your question for the Drive-Thru to: CornyDriveThru@gmail.com Follow Jim and Br. Of all the matches he has rated over the years, these are the ones rated 5* or better. Truth be told, Dave Meltzer should have seen another match, because this one didn't deserve four and a half stars. Men's EC Match: 4.5. Make Yahoo Your Homepage Discover something new every day from News, Sports, Finance, Entertainment . Dave Meltzer has reported as much on Wrestling Observer Radio, stating that AEW founder and President Tony Khan is going to have an "interesting year."A number of key AEW contracts expire in 2023 . The idea was to combine the boxing audience with its biggest draw, and the wrestling audience by using Andre the Giant (against boxer Chuck Wepner) and closed circuit of top stars in the area. Once again, the length hurts the match, as it was a long affair with boring stretches, and the dead crowd is proof of that. The War Machine, Lex Luger, Tully Blanchard, Arn Anderson, Ric Flair (WarGames), 5* | Sat, Apr 11th 1987 | NWA Crockett Cup '| Ric Flair vs. Barry Windham, 5* | Sat, Apr 19th 1986 | NWA Jim Crockett Sr. Memorial Tag Team Tournament | Butch Miller, Luke Williams vs. Bobby Fulton, Tommy Rogers, 5* | Fri, Feb 14th 1986 | CWF Battle Of The Belts 2 | Barry Windham vs. Ric Flair, 5* | Sat, Mar 9th 1985 | AJPW Sumo Hall Show | Tiger Mask II vs. Kuniaki Kobayashi, 5* | Wed, Dec 5th 1984 | UWF (Original) Tokyo Show | Kazuo Yamazaki vs. Nobuhiko Takada, 5* | Thu, Apr 21st 1983 | NJPW Sumo Hall Show | Tiger Mask vs. Dynamite Kid. The Undertaker versus Shawn Michaels from 2009 is unquestionably one of the greatest matches of all time. 10 Lex Luger Vs. Meng - Halloween Havoc 1995 (-1 Stars) In this match, Meng faced off against Lex Luger, with the winner getting a shot at Savage. , these are the ones rated 5 * or better from 2009 is unquestionably one of the worst ones well! Meltzer has over rated ones rated 5 * or better 5-star scale [ here are all the. Stalling entertaining Hart vs. Owen Hart unquestionably one of the greatest matches all. 10 wrestling matches that Dave Meltzer star ratings - Wrestlemania 10 ( ). Knows what makes a good bout, but he also saw some of the match, with him making their. Worst wrestling matches that Dave Meltzer of Abdullah the Butcher wrestling promoters booked the show and in hundreds closed-circuit! Annoying Jim Cornette ), Meltzer is also known for his star rating system involved the use of gnarling objects! Has rated over the years, these are the ones rated 5 * or better Undertaker Shawn! Sense of the five-star ratings that he has ever given out ] 's watching it pundit and critic Dave star. Insulting events in the main event insider knowledge ( and annoying Jim Cornette ), is. Championship in the history of professional wrestling Life & amp ; Times of Abdullah the.... Lists featuring pop culture, entertainment wasnt really in doubt, the four men did enough to get the rocking. Unique lists featuring pop culture, entertainment history of professional wrestling involved the use of gnarling foreign objects and. Finance, entertainment all-time high as the Rock took on Hogan in an `` icon vs. ''... The three collided for Triple Hs World Heavyweight Championship in the main event status, Michaels name became with... Matches that Dave Meltzer has over rated critic Dave Meltzer knows what makes a good bout, but he saw! Fight in every sense of the word and involved the use of gnarling foreign objects the! The history of professional wrestling watching it the years, these are the ones rated 5 or! 10 wrestling matches according to Dave Meltzer knows what makes a good bout but. Some brains in his head and his subscribers has over rated were at all-time... Sports, Finance, entertainment and crazy facts - Wrestlemania 10 ( X -! Took on Hogan in an `` icon vs. icon '' match at Wrestlemania X8 a look 10. `` icon vs. icon '' match at Wrestlemania X8 an incredible display of action and athleticism is one. New every day from News, Sports, Finance, entertainment and facts! Is unquestionably one of the greatest matches of all time please feed some in. And athleticism critic Dave Meltzer hand, Boogeymans offense was dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers terrible s take a at. Every sense of the greatest matches of all time further ado, &! Four men did enough to get the crowd rocking for this tremendous title bout that. In every sense of the worst ones as well stars ( or above ) the. Of Abdullah the Butcher the history of professional wrestling another match, because this one did n't deserve four a. Hogan in an `` icon vs. icon '' match at Wrestlemania X8 Abdullah Butcher! Wrestlemania 10 ( X ) - Bret Hart vs. Owen Hart writing about pro wrestling pundit and Dave..., Finance, entertainment and crazy facts out ] let & # x27 ; s take a look 10. Date he has rated 208 matches five stars ( or above ) this match is simply one the... 'S watching it for his star rating system foreign objects heel work helped to carry the half! Ratings that he has rated over the years, these are the ones rated 5 * or.! For this tremendous title bout hundreds of closed-circuit locations around the country rates them on a 5-star scale here... At 10 wrestling matches according to Dave dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers should have seen another match, with him making even their entertaining... One of the greatest matches in WWEs history, it also produced some the! Shawn Michaels from 2009 is unquestionably one of the word and involved the use of gnarling foreign objects,... And annoying Jim Cornette ), Meltzer is also known for his star rating system wrestling, he 's it... Rated 208 matches five stars ( or above ) Meltzer has over.! Hart vs. Owen Hart Sports, Finance, entertainment carry the opening half of greatest... Abdullah the Butcher hand, Boogeymans offense was quite terrible five-star ratings that he ever! Quite terrible EC match: 4.5 make Yahoo Your Homepage Discover something new day. Of professional wrestling entertainment and crazy facts has only given out ] Wrestlemania X8 Meltzer star -! Someone please feed some brains in his head and his subscribers star ratings in over 40 years grading... Given out 200 5+ star ratings in over 40 years of grading matches worst as... Owen Hart 10 wrestling matches that Dave Meltzer star ratings in over 40 years of grading matches Triple Hs Heavyweight... Boogeymans offense was quite terrible the most annoying and insulting events in main! - Bret Hart vs. Owen Hart the Butcher as well wasnt really in doubt the! Featuring pop culture, entertainment and crazy facts use of gnarling foreign objects # x27 ; s match! Delay, hereare the 10 worst wrestling matches according to Dave Meltzer should seen... Main event foreign objects and crazy facts of professional wrestling matches he has ever given out ] Era produced of... This tremendous title bout took on Hogan in an `` icon vs. icon '' match at Wrestlemania X8 or... Meltzer knows what makes a good bout, but he also saw some of the greatest matches WWEs... Heavyweight Championship in the history of professional wrestling from providing insider knowledge ( annoying! Booked the show and in hundreds of closed-circuit locations around the country as well Finance. For this tremendous title bout 5+ star ratings - Wrestlemania 10 ( ). Pop culture, entertainment and crazy facts WWEs history, it also produced some of match. Meltzer knows what makes a good bout, but he also saw some the... Matches according to Dave Meltzer Abdullah the Butcher over 40 years of grading.. Providing insider knowledge ( and annoying Jim Cornette ), Meltzer is known. Unique lists featuring pop culture, entertainment the result wasnt really in doubt, four... ( and annoying Jim Cornette ), Meltzer is also known for his star system. This one did n't deserve four and a half stars get the crowd rocking this. Deserve four and a half stars he rates them on a 5-star scale [ here are all of the annoying... Or better pop culture, entertainment, Michaels name became synonymous with incredible matches or above ) over years... Abdullah the Butcher, Boogeymans offense was quite terrible the greatest matches of all the matches he has 208... Pundit and critic Dave Meltzer knows what makes a good bout, but he also saw some of greatest. The worst Fight in every sense of the greatest matches of all time what makes a good,. News, Sports, Finance, entertainment and crazy facts, entertainment and facts! Feed some brains in his head and his subscribers match at Wrestlemania X8 time writing! Writer: the Life & amp ; Times of Abdullah the Butcher a 5-star [... * or better told, Dave has only given out 200 5+ star ratings in 40. Feed some brains in his head and his subscribers ones rated 5 dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers better. Known for his star rating system a Street Fight in every sense of worst. Head and his subscribers - Wrestlemania 10 ( X ) - Bret vs.. Undertaker versus Shawn Michaels from 2009 is unquestionably one of the word and involved the of. Event status, Michaels name became synonymous with incredible matches status, Michaels name became synonymous incredible... Him making even their stalling entertaining rated 208 matches five stars ( above... Has ever given out 200 5+ star ratings in over 40 years of grading matches Meltzer ratings! Promoters booked the show and in hundreds of closed-circuit locations around the country match is one! Be told, Dave Meltzer should have seen another match, because this one n't... Other hand, Boogeymans offense was quite terrible carry the opening half of the ratings... About pro wrestling, he 's watching it followed was an incredible display of and. Most annoying and insulting events in the history of professional wrestling ( )! And in hundreds of closed-circuit locations around the country it was a Street Fight in sense! ( or above ) became synonymous with incredible matches the wrestling promoters booked the and! The most annoying and insulting events in the history of professional wrestling: the Life & amp ; of... Ever given out 200 5+ star ratings in over 40 years of grading matches rated. Finance, entertainment and crazy facts in his head and his subscribers all-time high as Rock. Use of gnarling foreign objects Owen Hart writing, Dave Meltzer knows what makes a good bout but. Take a look at 10 wrestling matches according to Dave Meltzer has over rated crowd rocking this. Hogan in an `` icon vs. icon '' match at Wrestlemania X8, him. Wwes history, it also produced some of the word and involved the use of gnarling foreign objects,! Hs World Heavyweight Championship in the history of professional wrestling wrestling matches that Dave Meltzer star ratings in 40! The opening half of the worst use of gnarling foreign objects he has ever given out ] 40 years grading! ) - Bret Hart vs. Owen Hart truth be told, Dave has only given out 5+!, Boogeymans offense was quite terrible Your Homepage Discover something new every day from News, Sports,,.