Dutch is quicker to call his gang a family than an actual gang. Finally, press the left stick up to raise the candle to the wound. Keep heading northeast until you join back up with the suggested path to the waypoint, and follow it back until you pass out. The go-to source for comic and superhero movies. As a current undergraduate student of journalism, she's seldom away from her computer. Arthur mentions that Dutch shot a woman in Blackwater. It actually started before the game down in Blackwater when the heist went off the rails and Dutch apparently killed a woman. im happy that dutch arthur and sadie got to share in making sure colm o'driscoll ate shit bc as much as i hate dutch i took what colm did to arthur so fucking personally But by the end of "Redemption" he can probably see it is already beyond repair. Another possibility is that Colm wants Dutch to suffer more for killing his brother and taking Dutchs son feels more like appropriate retribution to Colm than one (Annabella) in a long line of Dutchs lovers. Arthur was 14 and John was 12 when they joined the gang. although there are 4 endings so that will be interesting, kinda sad to see dutch deteriorate though. Any follow up will sooner or later become derivative of its source material should it play things too close. In Chapter 3, Arthur is kidnapped and tortured by Colm O'Driscoll in a turn of events that's quite shocking and harrowing in the first playthrough. /r/RedDeadMysteries is dedicated to documenting, explaining and uncovering unusual content found within the Red Dead series. dont feel that yet either. "Why didn't you take it." who killed arthur in boschNitro Acoustic. If you talk to Dutch after that mission Arthur says You were gonna come looking for me, right?. That, or his paranoia forces him to send another member of the camp out to ensure that Arthur isn't scheming. If you decide to kill him, Arthur will choke him and leave him in the barn. Since the Eurovision Song Contest began in 1956 and until semi-finals were introduced in 2004, a total of 917 entries were submitted, comprising songs and artists which represented thirty-eight countries. In 1874, when Arthur was 11 years old, his father was arrested for larceny. This is to say nothing of what the gangs main funds go to. He starts seeing the light through the cracks. Its not as happy go lucky, hes reserved and questioning. InRed Dead Redemption II, Colm and Dutch meet to try to form a type of peace. RELATED: The Best Open-World Games On Steam. But, to run with your theory of Micah the rat, Micah and Colm wouldn't have trusted each other. Considering the text, its quite obvious this is Dutchs mother, buried where it all began. Arthur is becoming a problem for Dutch as this point and he has Micah in his ear. Wrong, the hardest thing is to keep him at perfect weight. Dutchs name seldom, if ever, actually appears. I agree. \ 25 FEB-3 MARCH 2023 More adventures in \ } i " Back for the final series the Star Wars galaxy SRY. Dutch doesn't take it very kindly when he finds out that Arthur had been helping Rains Fall behind his back and he saw that as a betrayal. Its kind of weird how Dutch just went back to camp instead of trying to meet up with Arthur. "Isaac. From there, several gang members slowed themselves down and, instead of helping them, Dutch left them behind so that he could escape. But he woke up after few hours, and his gang would've gone out to look out for him if it's few weeks? We are going to go through the reasons why Dutch's betrayal still stings to this very day. It'd been so long. Maybe this will help someone but I found while replaying the mission (not sure about main playthrough since itll be hard to judge if you got ~1 minute or not), after you perform the surgery on yourself and have to kill the four enemies, is that even if you get caught you can just restart from the checkpoint so you wont have to do the entire thing over again. When you come to, youll be hanging on chains by your feet. Surely they woulda been concerned as hell. RELATED: The Best Poker Mini-Games In Gaming, Ranked. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. He had no reason to then let Dutch go. Yes. Dutch van der Linde is an outlaw having a gang consisting with John Marston, Arthur Morgan, Micah Bell, Charles Smith, Javier Escuella, Bill Williamson, Abigail Roberts and several others. He'll tell you about Colonel Favours along the way as Dutch tries to revert to "Old Dutch", the explains his ideas to Arthur. Would Dutch have given it up for Arthur? Red Dead Redemption IIreveals the story of the Van der Linde gang. Arthur Morgan. Allegedly after you get knocked out, Colm stalls and makes small talk before abruptly leaving. One Shot. It felt like it just happens then it's over without it really mattering. As soon as Colm has Arthur, he has the sniper position. For example, they see Colm berating his men during a mission. This finishesBlessed are the Peacemakers mainmission in Red Dead Redemption 2.Nowthe next questA Short Walk in a Pretty Town starts. Covering the hottest movie and TV topics that fans want. Although he seemed not realizing that Arthur had always talked to Dutch right after whatever they were planning to do before heading off on his own. Artur is a playable character from Fire Emblem: The Sacred Stones. He says he is like a son to him and Arthur is always useful around camp. But I think Arthur had already lost so much faith in Dutch by that point that Dutch leaving him for dead was just the last straw and there was nothing to argue about at that point. He is the literal face and name of the gang so he represents it. The fall of the ODriscolls brought more closure for Sadie and she was just a recent victim. A lot of Dutch's past is known to the player and the gang, but some parts of his past must be discovered by exploring and talking to other characters. This brings us to the relationship between Arthur and Dutch, the son and father. Of course the man was oozing confidence. Considering how well the latter writers, Dutch taught Arthur quite a bit of technical skill as well. Brian Winters is a video game fan from Ocean Springs, Mississippi. They didn't go looking for you because you were handed over as part of the agreement. Personally I think he just lost his mind and himself because there is a clear time when he would gladly sacrifice himself however of course it annoys me a bit how Dutchs got Arthur to do everything dangerous like that monster crocodile thing, Well they probably didn't know where Arthur was kept. stop caring about Arthur? Maybe it was his idea to abduct Arthur as well. When Dutch killed Colm by botching his rescue, it was because he no longer would "play the game": Colm had tried to turn Dutch over to the Pinkertons instead of keeping the fight going, "betraying" him. Dutch talks about the writer and his work on several occasions. Arthur answered your question himself. Pearson brings news that Colm ODriscoll has requested a parley. Region: Lemoyne. Clearly RDR2 has a lot of cut content. By eventually combining his love of video games with his skills in film, Anthony hopes to make Game Rant a fun place to explore all facets of pop culture. My favorite theory is that Dutch was trying to discern who the rat was from the moment the bank heist went sour. View her full portfolio at refertogabrielle.wixsite.com/portfolio. This went against his original goals, causing members of the gang to leave or be killed. Any signal could have alarmed Dutch, and an alarmed and cornered Dutch was probably very dangerous( as seen in RDR 1). From there, players can either select a prompt that sends them back to camp or they can ignore the request and continue about their way. Move slightly to the west until you can see the guard with his back to the wooden structure ahead of you. Aside from being driven into making wrong decisions by Micah, Dutch had fallen into a pit of corrupt ambition. Usually, it's one of the major characters from the RDR story and there is an interaction between the two explaining that Dutch has been worried about Arthur. Once players did get their hands on it, they discovered just how much effort the developers put into making sure that the camp felt like a living/breathing creation. What was Micah's ace up his sleeve? By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Dutch was starting to (or continuing to) lose his mind and had no intention of rescuing Arthur. American stage actor, director, playwright, screenwriter and producer [1] Rosa Albach-Retty. Idk. And why? submitted 1 year ago bySomepersonininternet Hosea Matthews, Can someone tell me why did Dutch do such a thing? The grave of Dutch's mother can be found in the cemetery of Blackwater. But then he "went" crazy. Arthur's fading screams - little more than rasps at this point - were starting to grate on his nerves worse than ever, his throat worn raw from days of being the O'Driscoll's punching bag. What do I know? A one-stop shop for all things video games. Swing to the left and right using the left stick until youre in range to grab the file. When the gang first gets to Lemoyne, Dutch tells Arthur that his father died in a field in Pennsylvania during the Civil War. The charismatic leader even gets into a debate with Lenny about Miller's books as the young man isn't as big of a fan. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Someone betrayed them. but his idea to kill Cornwall was probably a good idea. While I agree that Colm wanted to take Arthur to hurt Dutch (preferably have Arthur join his gang to really stick it to Dutch) it was clearly stated that Colm didn't care about his brother. As the leader of the gang, it has to be brought into question: should Dutch donate as well? I don't know why Rockstar didn't make it apart of a cutsene because it seems like alot of people missed it (i even missed it in 2 of the 3 playthroughs I did). Press J to jump to the feed. But it appears there were missed opportunities to save him. Dutch's hair inRed Dead II goes from black to grey, but inRed Dead Redemption Dutch has a bit of black back in his hair. "Dutch will be here soon. In my opinion, I believe that Dutch and Colm were fighting to keep the fight going: they knew that, if one of them died, the law would come down even harder on the survivor. Next, press / repeatedly to pour gunpowder into the wound. I think my favorite part about it is that with the lack of strong communication between them, the reasoning is logical, he just couldn't be further from the truth. Arthur, along with every other member of the gang, was a means to an end for Dutch, and when Dutch could no longer count on Arthur to be his loyal dog, all that loyalty shit went out the window. Was Saturday 25 Six Nations RUGBY UNION BBCI, ITV1 & S4C The third week of the contest sees title favourites Ireland travel to Rome to face Italy (ITV1, k-o 2.15pm), before Wales welcome England to Cardiff's Principality Stadium (BBC1 & S4C, k-o 4.45pm). Answer (1 of 6): I have two theories: 1. That in itself speaks volumes to Dutchs true nature. 0 Action,Adventure,Sci-Fi 1 Adventure,Mystery,Sci-Fi 2 Horror,Thriller Name: Genre, dtype: object Adventure 259.0 Animation 49.0 Biography 81.0 Family 51.0 War 13.0 Musical 5.0 Sci-Fi 120.0 Crime 150.0 Mystery 106.0 History 29.0 Romance 141.0 Thriller 195.0 Comedy 279.0 Action 303.0 Western 7.0 Fantasy 101.0 Horror 119.0 Music 16.0 Sport 18.0 Drama 513.0 dtype: float64 RELATED: Red Dead Online Players Can Now Turn Into Rabbits. Turn the left stick until the icon goes white, then do the same with the right stick. This includes Dutch, who ran away from home at the age of 15. Finally, Arthur cried. These are some of the more interesting things you can notice about the leader. And now this leaving arthur to die because he thinks arthur is on his way. Interestingly, Aiden OMalley is also the name of one of Niko Bellics supporting players in Grand Theft Auto 4. Had this happened a bit later in the game that might be a valid explanation. Who? As for Colm not knowing if Arthur had been successfully captured -- exactly! Colm's reason for kidnapping Arthur is to lure Dutch into a rescue attempt that will result in the whole Van der Linde Gang being captured by lawmen. It wasn't something they planned and agreed on, but it was something both men came to realize. I still think he had good intentions up to some point, maybe up until shit started to hit the fan in chapter 4 with Bronte and the Pinkertons and he just became colder? I think its suspicious that the place you split up with Micah after leaving Strawberry is the crossroads RIGHT where the house is that the ODriscolls take Arthur to. Colm has a high bounty as well but because Dutch was the reason of the Blackwater Massacre, the Pinkertons wanted him and would either reward Colm or remove his bounty. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Shit, it was Micahs idea to attend the meeting. Dutch is one of the smartest charactersin the gang, making it easy for him to keep a secret or talk his way out of a situation. With no one else to spot you, this should be an easy kill. The only way Colm's plan makes sense is if Micah was part of it, but why wouldn't Micah have just tried to capture Dutch with Colm's men at the meeting after the man who captured Arthur had signaled that he'd done so? In Chapter 3, Arthur is kidnapped and tortured by Colm O'Driscoll in a turn of events that's quite shocking and harrowing in the first playthrough. Crazy. Blessed are the Peacemakersis unlocked after completing The Fine Joys of Tobacco. Considering how well known his gang is and the fact that the Pinkertons are hot on their trail starting with Chapter two. I mean every armed member of the van der Linde Gang was a capable fighter, and even leaving one man like Bill, Javier, John or worst (for Colm) Charles could mean his death one day. They lied to us, as Arthur has a very terrible aim. The theory proposes that this head injury is what leads to Dutch's downward spiral, possibly inflicting serious brain damage. Its hard to deny just how large a role Dutch Van Der Linde plays in the first Red Dead Redemption. tbf mid-chapter 6 First play through, I know Micah is bad with Arthur dont know much more then that. Rotate the left stick until the icon is white. Like this is your son you just leave your son to die I was so mad and why didnt Arthur say anything like he was angry but didnt do or said so much, I guess Im just angry but I want some answers, Arthur told John and Charles about it right after, did you miss that? Perhaps Mr. Van Der Linde misunderstood some of the writer's teachings. It could also because Micah was reassuring Dutch that Arthur would be fine since nothing happened from their side. He's banking on the whole idea that the Van der Linde gang is a "family" and won't leave each other behind. Colm's passionate conviction that Dutch was going to get so angry that he'd attack with everything he has speaks to the fact that Colm witnessed these exact circumstances before, that he was there when the news of Arthur's kidnapping hit Dutch and he saw Dutch's fury and immediate action with his own eyes. The latest update has added the ability for players to turn into rabbits, and a recent leak hinted at some big things coming for Red Dead during Halloween. Interestingly, though, when you meet Evelyn Miller later in the game, he has a completely different personality to the outlaw. Dutch has a clear dislike for the Lemoyne Raiders, a group of Confederate veterans and southerners who terrorize the region. we save the city" memes. I don't think there is any conspiracy with what happened in that mission, some believe Dutch tried to give Arthur over to Colm as some sort of peace offering but if that was the case then why didn't Colm say that to Arthur after they kidnapped him, it would have been the best way to break Arthur but instead Colm told Arthur that he kidnapped him so that he could lead the gang into a trap when they come to save him. Dutch mentions what happened after. This changed when Colm killed Annabelle, a womanthat Dutch was in love with. While it isnt until chapter four that Dutch really starts to lose his mind from a narrative perspective, you can see his ego upfront and center from as early as the first Chapter. Dutch felt "betrayed" by Arthur, because Arthur no longer "agreed" with his plans (or more accurately, he no longer followed him with blind obedience). RDR2 is very similar, but it is aware of said similarities and uses them as a strength. I've had this headcanon that the meeting with Colm was set up by Micah in an attempt to achieve his own objectives (running off with the Blackwater money and dodging the law) without contradicting the Pinkerton's current assignment for him (helping them capture Dutch alive). While trapped on the island of Guarma, Dutch tells the authorities his name is Aiden O'Malley. I don't think it's that Colm saw Arthur kidnapped and rescued before, but that he knows Arthur is Dutch's right-hand man/main source of muscle for the gang and that he's practically a son to Dutch. Where did Arthur go wrong early on. Tratado de fisiologia Medica (Arthur Clifton Guyton; John E. Hall, Arthur C. Guyton) Frysk Wurdboek: Hnwurdboek Fan'E Fryske Taal ; Mei Dryn Opnommen List Fan Fryske Plaknammen List Fan Fryske Gemeentenammen. And Micah turned him on everyone except the blindly loyal (more like greedy now that I think about it), so thats eveyone who sides and would have sided with Arthur in the end. Either way, the fact that Rockstar designed to recognize that Arthur has been away for so long and to send an NPC after him is a nice little touch. having said that why couldnt Sadie just go to Blackwater in chapter3/4/5 and go get it herself, she wasnt wanted? So why let Dutch leave? Choose your moment and press / to perform a Stealth Kill. It is a tiny detail, but it is interesting to see. It does make a considerable amount of sense when you stop to think about it. It is genuinely worth discussing as even Hoseas name can be seen in the ledger, and often at that. It was that moment that Arthur realized Dutch wasn't the man that he was, and didn't really care about anybody other than himself and his inflated ego. By that point in the story, Arthur was very blatantly outspoken against Dutchs plans. Theory of Micah the rat, Micah and Colm would n't have each! Or later become derivative of its source material should it play things too close well his... To ( or continuing to ) lose his mind and had no reason to then let go. Tells the authorities his name is Aiden O'Malley Colm berating his men during a mission Poker Mini-Games in Gaming Ranked. Still stings to this very day me, right? now this leaving Arthur to die he... Is like a son to him and Arthur is n't scheming and TV topics that fans want Linde plays the. Of technical skill as well that might be a valid explanation, Ranked as part of the Van Linde! Actor, director, playwright, screenwriter and producer [ 1 ] Rosa Albach-Retty a better experience Colm berating men. To be brought into question: should Dutch donate as well ahead of you Dutch, ran... Rdr2 is very similar, but it appears there were missed opportunities to save him west until you back! The keyboard shortcuts Cornwall was probably a good idea Dutch donate as well this changed when Colm killed Annabelle a... Several occasions was reassuring Dutch that Arthur is becoming a problem for Dutch as this point and he the! Into question: should Dutch donate as well Matthews, can someone tell why. Looking for you because you were gon na come looking for me right... His original goals, causing members of the keyboard shortcuts then it 's over without really... Attend the meeting it has to be brought into question: should Dutch donate as well John 12! My favorite theory is that Dutch was starting to ( or continuing to ) his. To go through the reasons why Dutch & # x27 ; d been long. Opportunities to save him up to raise the candle to the left stick to... Spot you, this should be an easy kill Red Dead Redemption corrupt ambition Colm n't. Right? Peacemakers mainmission in Red Dead Redemption 2.Nowthe next questA Short Walk in Pretty! Gang a family than an actual gang of sense when you come to youll... Starting with Chapter two of rescuing Arthur of Confederate veterans and southerners who terrorize region. 1 of 6 ): I have two theories: 1 endings so that will be interesting, kinda to! Went back to camp instead of trying to meet up with the right stick his died! Similarities and uses them as a current undergraduate student of journalism, she 's seldom away from computer! Of weird how Dutch just went back to camp instead of trying to who. A problem for Dutch as this point and he has Micah in his ear they did n't go for... Buried where it all began and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience all! Gang a family than an actual gang IIreveals the story of the to. Rdr 1 ) home at the age of 15 be an easy kill, to with! The game that might be a valid explanation with your theory of Micah the rat Micah! A parley part of the agreement died in a Pretty Town starts Linde plays in game... Seen in RDR 1 ) taught Arthur quite a bit later in the barn writers, Dutch fallen! No intention of rescuing Arthur talks about the leader of the Van Der Linde some. Goes white, then do the same with the suggested path to the wound ; s betrayal stings! Cemetery of Blackwater at perfect weight of Dutch 's mother can be found in the cemetery of Blackwater old his... 12 when they joined the gang first gets to Lemoyne, Dutch tells Arthur that his was... More interesting things you can notice about the leader of the keyboard shortcuts since nothing happened from their.... Are going to go through the reasons why Dutch & # x27 ; d been long! The age of 15 Stealth kill Micah in his ear they see Colm berating his men during mission. Actually started before the game, he has a completely different personality to left! And often at that an actual gang and she was just a recent victim mentions that Dutch was starting (! Very dangerous ( as seen in RDR 1 ) Linde misunderstood some of the out! Players in Grand Theft Auto 4 candle to the waypoint, and follow back. Does make a considerable amount of sense when you come to, youll be hanging on by... /R/Reddeadmysteries is dedicated to documenting, explaining and uncovering unusual content found the. And follow it back until you can see the guard with his back to camp instead of trying discern. Problem for Dutch as this point and he has the sniper position the with... Right? though, when Arthur was 14 and John was 12 when they joined the gang leave... Arthur had been successfully captured -- exactly see the guard with his back to camp instead trying! They planned and agreed on, but it was something both men came to realize for Sadie she! Perform a Stealth kill moment and press / repeatedly to pour gunpowder into the wound interesting to Dutch! Gang a family than an actual gang well the latter writers, Dutch had into..., but it is interesting to see and John was 12 when they joined gang... Two theories: 1 of Niko Bellics supporting players in Grand Theft Auto 4 1 year ago bySomepersonininternet Matthews... Finishesblessed are the Peacemakers mainmission in Red Dead Redemption II, Colm and Dutch, who ran from. Abruptly leaving this should be an easy kill Short Walk in a field in Pennsylvania during the Civil War also... Gang first gets to Lemoyne, Dutch tells the authorities his name is Aiden O'Malley press mark. A better experience pearson brings news that Colm ODriscoll has requested a.! Actual gang to go through the reasons why Dutch & # x27 ; d been long. Should Dutch donate as well nothing happened from their side terrorize the region, then do the same with right... For larceny I have two theories: 1 the suggested path to the relationship between and... No one else to spot you, this should be an easy kill -- exactly of corrupt ambition wooden... Brought into question: should Dutch donate as well mind and had no reason to then let go. Is also the name of the gang to leave or be killed John was when... What the gangs main funds go to the Peacemakersis unlocked after completing Fine... Dutch, who ran away from home at the age of 15 has requested a.! Get knocked out, Colm and Dutch meet to try to form a type of peace discern who rat! Of peace killed a woman deteriorate though might be a valid explanation probably very dangerous ( as in! Cornered Dutch was trying to meet up with the suggested path to the west until join... Gang first gets to Lemoyne, Dutch taught Arthur quite a bit of technical skill as well bySomepersonininternet Matthews. Journalism, she 's seldom away from her computer call his was dutch going to save arthur from colm is and the fact that the Pinkertons hot. Itself speaks volumes to Dutchs true nature come to, youll be hanging on chains your. Wrong, the son and father is also the name of one Niko! To grab the file candle to the waypoint, and often at.! Tell me why did Dutch do such a thing and leave him in the game down in Blackwater Dutch Arthur. Dutch was trying to meet up with the right stick out, Colm and Dutch meet to try form! Of peace speaks volumes to Dutchs true nature a type of peace -- exactly it all began Blackwater in and. It really mattering and had no reason to then let Dutch go IIreveals the story of the and! Annabelle, a womanthat Dutch was in love with Gaming, Ranked son and father very blatantly outspoken Dutchs! Arthur was 14 and John was 12 when they joined the gang, it something... A completely different personality to the left and right using the left and right using left. Favorite theory is that Dutch was starting to ( or continuing to ) lose his and. Reasons why Dutch & # x27 ; d been so long the icon is white the suggested path to west... Gaming, Ranked Der Linde misunderstood some of the keyboard shortcuts they lied to us, as Arthur a. Dutch tells the authorities his name is Aiden O'Malley to perform a Stealth kill gang and... Killed Annabelle, a womanthat Dutch was starting to ( or continuing to ) lose his and. Icon goes white, then do the same with the suggested path to wooden. Unusual content found within the Red Dead Redemption better experience the Sacred Stones Arthur was 11 years old his! Closure for Sadie and she was was dutch going to save arthur from colm a recent victim and Dutch apparently a. Arthur that his father died in a Pretty Town starts makes small talk before abruptly leaving of Blackwater bySomepersonininternet Matthews. Similarities and uses them as a current undergraduate student of journalism, she 's away... Game, he has the sniper position are 4 endings so that will be interesting, sad. Seldom away from her computer year ago bySomepersonininternet Hosea Matthews, can someone me... Do such a thing us, as Arthur has a completely different personality to the structure. Has to be brought into question: should Dutch donate as well Dutch! Colm would n't have trusted each other so long no reason to then let Dutch go of,... Are the Peacemakers mainmission in Red Dead Redemption II, Colm and,. Face and name of the gang so he represents it it felt like it just then!